News:

Welcome ZX10R Ninja Owners!!!!!
Front Page Here
Can all new members that haven't posted please read the admin and announcement page for the forum rules.

Main Menu

A fu@kin disgrace !

Started by 10RDan, February 19, 2013, 11:26:33 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

10RDan

 :iamwithstupid:As above.

http://www.motorcyclenews.com/MCN/News/newsresults/General-news/2013/February/feb1913-death-crash-policewoman-escapes-charges/Post.aspx?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter

Regardless of the fact that the person "killed" was a biker and she was a cop, although it does rub me up the wrong way, she should've had the fuckin book thrown at her.

If I remember correctly, a few years back a politician, I think,  was convicted of causing an accident on a motorway. He wasn't using the phone at the the time but they found out from his phone records that he'd sent a text some time previous to the accident and was, therefore, to blame.

I'm in no way condoning what he did, but where the fuck is the continuity in the "law" ?  [wall]
Race In Peace #58

andicog

#1
Absolute disgrace , this country is screwed, its like all the MP's that got caught stealing expenses , they were made to pay it back, try that if your ever caught working whilst claiming benefit . . . . . . . .
Age And Treachery Shall Always Triumph Over Youth And Skill . . . . . . .

Bobtra69

Yep, saw this on MCN website this morning (think mine was the third response), an absolute disgrace, they look after their own don't they?

Am i alone in thinking if this was joe public they would have at least had a conviction of some kind (but then again she was a car driver!)?

The fact she lied in court as well and didn't get any reprimand for that stinks as well!

I tell you, we really are up against it in this country - if it isn't getting knocked off our bikes by blind car drivers, being persecuted by the coppers for even thinking of riding a bike, then the justice system doesn't even hold up it's end.

My greatest respects to this chap's family.

goldie

#3
There never there when you need them and always there when you dont :boxing:

NinjaPaul

Its a shame cases like this arent decided on balance of probability rather than provable facts. Fucking hag deserves to rot in jail IMHO  [wall]

10RDan

#5
Quote from: NinjaPaul on February 19, 2013, 10:12:41 PM
Its a shame cases like this arent decided on balance of probability rather than provable facts. Fucking hag deserves to rot in jail IMHO  [wall]

I hear what you're sayin, but "balance of probability" doesn't really come into it. She admitted bein on the phone for all of journey. Phone records would prove it too, if it was you or me it would have been "proven".
Race In Peace #58

NellyB

She gets off with charge in quick time yet friends of mine are still being dragged through the courts 2 years after the death of a husband n wife who were travelling in a group on bikes in Tadcaster. They have only just got there bikes back and still are not allowed on the road on them due to bail restrictions. Even though a single charge has not been proven.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/133717773368313/

Their lives have been ruined by the UK CPS Justice system and all because they stopped to help their friends when they crashed.

I thought Chicken strips were meant for restaurants

Bobtra69

Is that still on going? Bugger me that's mental!!!!

NinjaPaul

Quote from: 10RDan on February 20, 2013, 08:16:52 AM
Quote from: NinjaPaul on February 19, 2013, 10:12:41 PM
Its a shame cases like this arent decided on balance of probability rather than provable facts. Fucking hag deserves to rot in jail IMHO  [wall]

I hear what you're sayin, but "balance of probability" doesn't really come into it. She admitted bein on the phone for all of journey. Phone records would prove it too, if it was you or me it would have been "proven".

I take your point. The CPS are a bunch of spineless cunts that like to work 'when it suits' and don't like to go after their own kind even if they're guilty as hell. I know from personal experience myself when the CPS shafted me after I was almost killed in a road accident and didn't prosecute the guilty party because of his legal connections.  [wall]

NellyB

Quote from: Bobtra69 on February 20, 2013, 08:41:42 AM
Is that still on going? Bugger me that's mental!!!!
Yeah they are back in court on the 22 feb for some more bullshite :boxing:

I thought Chicken strips were meant for restaurants

Bobtra69

Quote from: NellyB on February 20, 2013, 02:18:40 PM
Quote from: Bobtra69 on February 20, 2013, 08:41:42 AM
Is that still on going? Bugger me that's mental!!!!
Yeah they are back in court on the 22 feb for some more bullshite :boxing:

Good luck to them. Pass on my regards please (I don't know them but this case kind of shocked me when it first emerged).

robbosliding

#11
There are some very niave people commenting on this with some very deluded opinions. When did anyone believe the CPS were anything but incompetent? Lets put a few things in perspective here. The JURY will find a plea if CPS actually run a case, not the police or the CPS.
Who charged this woman? The Police did. Were they looking after their own, no. They charged her. Who attempted to prosecute her? The CPS did. Would the Police defend a Special Constable? No, they'd drop her like a stone. Most criminal cases fail because of how feeble CPS are - they want it in bag, CCTV, model witness, etc or they don't run the case. 90% of shits walk away without charge because a case might fail over a technicality and CPS don't want to run failed cases. This benefits the criminals, it happens on a daily basis, not to Police but criminals. Now lets put the boot on the other foot. Without undisputable evidence innocent people would go to prison, I'm talking not beyond all reasonable doubt but the balance of probabilties - I don't know the full facts here re who did what re overtaking on a junction but the offence of Death by Careless Driving (not to be confused with Death by Dangerous Driving, a completely different offence with a much, much higher threshold of bad driving evidence required) is a very worry offence which was introduced to appease a blame seeking public distraught by drivers charged with DBDD walking out of court with 3 points due to lack of said evidence. In essence any of us could have an accident (it happens hundreds of times a day) but if through unfortunate circumstances it proves fatal you may go to prison. This happened to my friend. On a dark, single carriageway country lane in drizzle. He is driving his car with wife and baby. He ran into a poor man stood in front of his parked cars rear light cluster (lights of facing oncoming traffic with lights on facing him) outside a rural property. It killed him outright. It destroyed my friend and the family of the victim who I also know. They charged him with DBCD. He was found guilty at a Crown Court. There was no evidence to suggest excess speed, no reckless element, he simply did not see him. The police no longer believe "accidents happen" they call them collisions and someone is always at fault - very worrying. My friend was sentenced. My friend was a Police Inspector, his wife a Police Sgt. To suggest they "look after their own" is so inaccurate, so ignorant it disgusts me. He was treated harshly because of who he was. Infact the rozzers are more likely to be arrested or charged with offence at the slightest suggestion of wrong doing - another shocker - cop chases fail to stop illegal immigrant who crashes and kills an innocent motorist - cop is arrested for DBDD as he was deemed to have "pushed" the offender into it - Arrested 3 times over 36 months facing the sack and prison . A Crown Court JURY found him not guilty and the Judge criticised CPS for bringing him to court. The police don't get an easy ride, to think otherwise is a million miles away from the truth.
This woman like most people facing jail will lie to save her own skin, how many here have argued "Maybe 80 or 90 Officer, 100mph no way......" People lie when caught but the interrogation of her phone showed otherwise.
The bikers death is a tragedy. I wonder how many on here with such anti rozzer attitudes "just" answer the phone whislt driving as numerous drivers I see do routinely. 99% of the time no problems. When it goes wrong though its big time shit but cretins still carry on doing it, because they are selfish and lazy. If there was suggestion that the bike was overtaking (I'm speculating) then the distraction of a phone on a lap or otherwise would not be the only contributing factor. Would you want to go to prison for a momentary lapse of concentration or error of judgement? We have all missed seeing a bike or cycle at least once no matter how careful a driver we are. A very worrying offence Death By Careless Driving, but by the grace of God go I..........and many others no doubt. Prosecuting someone doesn't bring someone back - it deters other offenders (apparently) and punishes the offender. I am happy with the offence of Death By Dangerous Driving but the offence of Death by Careless really worries me. I am not defending using the phone. If I had my way using a hand held phone should attract seizure and destruction of the phone and an instant 6 month ban with £1000 fine. Idiots might think twice then. I respect the Police they do a very difficult job, of course they fu*k up and there are bad apples but they do a dangerous and unpleasant job.

NellyB

 [clap] Glad thats cleared up then robbosliding  [clap] :cry:

I thought Chicken strips were meant for restaurants

10RDan

While I take your point re. police looking after police, that wasn't the point of the post.

The point was there dosen't appear to be a level playing field re. some convictions. As I stated in the OP, the fact that a "biker" was killed and she was a cop is irrelevant. Somebody was AND she initially lied and then admitted to "being on the phone" for all of the journey so it was hardly a "momentary lapse of concentration".

Even if the bike was overtaking or not is irrelevant, to a certain extent, because he wasn't speeding to do so AND, if he was overtaking she may not have seen him but that means she would have pulled out in front of the other vehicle anyway.

COMPLETE LACK OF CONCENTRATION
Race In Peace #58

robbosliding

Yes I agree with you in the main. The Criminal Justice System is far from perfect and people who have that expectation are blessed that they have not had a bad experience with it. I'm not trying to split hairs with what you have said but simply illustrate how the CPS work - If there was a suggestion (I don't know the facts) that the rider overtook on or on the approach to a junction (which places the rider in a blind spot to the emerging driver) the defence will argue he was at fault, speed is not a relevant factor but a rule of the High Way Code is broken and an endorsable offence committed by the rider. It will be argued it was a contributing factor to the collision. The Defence will argue that the "poor car driver" had no chance to see the motorcyclist whether on the phone or not - it reduces the "due care" element diluting it to a mere lesser mobile phone offence which won't have been charged as its two bites at the cherry. The Prosecution will see the defence and not want to argue and risk losing a case (CJS stats - broken and cracked cases, been there for some 7 years now). This type of thing happens all the time and the guilty party benefits from it, this makes good media headlines to have a go at the Police who by the sound of things did everything to put this driver in front of a Crown Court.  I have been on the recieving end of this imperfect system but I don't call into question the integrity of the police because of it and I know you didn't as the original topic poster. It is simply a far from fair or perfect system.
Death by Careless really concerns me. The lady across the road from me lost her husband in a motorcyle accident - he was the rider, overtaking, safely and legally on a rural road - a van he was following turned right as he went to overtake running him off the road and into an offside telegraph pole. He died at the scene. The police arrested the driver and the collision investigated but no charges were raised. I put myself in both positions -rider and driver. As the rider I'd be looking for turnings and speed of said van to suggest he might turn. Accelarate hard and early to bypass that risk or wait and hang back. The sun might have been in his eyes, he might not have seen the indication. The rider has made some, perhaps limited errors or misjudgements that led to the collision. He might also have accelarated up on the van quickly with the sun to the rear, the driver might never have known he was there, no internal mirror, rider in his blind spot. So its all the riders fault.......maybe.
Or the van driver - (A) He's old, been driving years, never had an accident (caused dozens though....), he's driven the route hundreds of times to his allotment. He can't see anyone behind him so doesn't indicate. Bang. (B) He's a careful driver but his indicator bulb failed this morning, the rider did all of the above. Bang. (C) He's not talking on the phone, he's just looking if his wife has text him, turns, bang. (D) He's an imcompetent old bastard that should have been off the roads years ago. Bang. (E) He was on the piss the night before but actually made no driving errors - the bike was found to be at excess speed-Bang- drivers fault. Jail.
My rather long and drawn out point is that a minor infringement or error IF by circumstance it goes horribly wrong can land you in jail. The offence of Death by Careless Driving worries me. Dangerous Driving carries such a greater burden of evidence to prove that you have to do something really excessive to get done for it. Lets not kid ourselves - and I am no angel. We know that execess of 100mph can attract a ban. We here all know 100mph is easy to do in a controlled and mainly safe manner, right time and place and all that. To do 160mph (for example) on a road, right time and place is not inhererantly dangerous (we will do it all day long at Waddington track event and the world won't stop spinning) but we all know that the law sees it as dangerous driving. The line drawn is in the sand. I would prefer to see big fines as oposed to jail where no one is injured in such an offence. As for phones they should be crushed, driver banded for 6 months and fined £1000 in my opinion. I have to agree that a burglar who gets a suspended sentence, Community Service or whatever compared to a speeding motorist (taxed, insured, licenced and working etc) gets jailed for simple excess speed it is all wrong. Completely wrong. The CJS is far from perfect. But be very wary of supporting a jail sentence for a motorist that has made a minor error. In the case here, if it was proven she was on the phone and a lack of concentration caused the accident entirely jail her. Simply because an accident occurs and someone dies it s not a reason to jail someone.